哈迪萨事件的英文wiki资料以及IMDB影评

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_for_HadithaBattleforHaditha(film)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haditha_killingsHadithakillingsgoogletranslatehttp://translate.google.com.hk/?hl=zh-TWtab=wT-------------------------------http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0870211/reviews影评65outof83peoplefoundthefollowingreviewuseful:PowerfulProvocativeFilm,12November20078/10Author:BlackNarcissusfromMaidaVale,UKIsawthisfilmatitsLondonpremiereattheOdeonWestEndaspartoftheLondonFilmFestival.IguessNickBroomfieldwasgettingsicktiredofseeingMichaelMoorerippingoffhisDocumentarystylesomadethishisSecondfeaturefilminasmanyyears.Liketheearlierfilm,Ghosts(www.imdb.com/title/tt0872202/),theBattleforHadithaisbasedonfact.ThefilmtellsstoryoftheeventsofNovember19,2005,whenatroopofUSMarinesexactrevengeforanearlierattackwhichkilledoneoftheirnumberintheIraqitownofHaditha.TheFilmfocusesonthreedifferentviewpoints,thefirstofIraqiinsurgents,whichinthiscaseisntsomemadMullahbutanoldman,whowelearnisanex-Armyofficerandhisson.ThesecondfocusesonaCorporalRuiz,ayoungMarinewhoyoufeelwantstobeanywherebutIraqiandthefinallythefilmfocusesonayoungIraqicoupleandtheirextendedfamily.ThefilmisshotCinéma-véritéstyleandattimesisveryharrowing.ButitstoBroomfieldscreditthathetomymindhedoesntsimplydemonizetheUSsoldiers.Insteadyougettounderstandhowyoungmenputinasituationthatyoutheviewercouldntunderstandletalonecopewith,couldjustloseitafteracomradeiskilled.Likewise,inthefilmsportrayaloftheinsurgentfightersBroomfieldmanagestomakeyouthinkwhatwouldyoudo,if,asinthefilm,youraprofessionalsoldiermadejoblessbyaanOccupyingforce.Howdoyoufeedyourfamily,andwouldntyoufeelsomeresentmenttotheoccupationforcesformakingyoujobless.ButitsintheIraqifamilies,caughtbetweentheUSforcesandtheInsurgentsthatthefilmisatitsbest.Theycantdotherightthingfordoingwrong.ItistheywhobearthebruntofeitherInsurgencyretaliationorUSForcesheavy-handedness.TheywhoultimatelywillandarethelosersinFilm.Thisisapowerfulfilmwhichdealswithallaspectsoftheproblemfairmindedly,butdoesntshyawayfromthetruth.DontletthosewhohaventwatchedthefilmputyouoffseeingthebestportrayaloftheWaronTerrortodate.BlackNarcissus--------------------------------------------------71outof95peoplefoundthefollowingreviewuseful:Mademecry.,21March20089/10Author:bluelionkMademecry.OnlyissuesInoticedare:ThatthetranslationofthespokenArabicissometimesmisleadingandhasnorelationwithwhattheyactuallysaid.SomeoftheactorsaccentsarenotIraqi(Palestian,Egyptian,andothers...),butmostareIraqis.ItsstillagreatmoviethatshowswhathappensinIraq,andthatwarisugly.Itsoneoftheraremoviesthatshowtheissuefromtheotherside.Theactingisgreat,soisthescenery(itdoeslookalotlikeIraq).Isayitagain,itmademecry,alot.--------------------------------------------------48outof75peoplefoundthefollowingreviewuseful:IfYouLikedBloodySundayUnited93,19September20079/10Author:Movie-JayfromToronto,CanadaIjustsawthismovieattheTorontoFilmFestival,anditsgoingtocreatemuchcontroversyastheweekspassuntilthisfilmfinallyopens.Ithinkthosewhoareagainstamoviebeforetheyevenseeitaresayingsomethingaboutthemselves,notthefilm.Watchit,andthenmakeupyourmind.Thismovie,likeUnited93orBloodySunday,istoldmomenttomoment,keepsitsheaddownandjustmovesforwardwithoutjudgmentorcommentary.Themovieisntawareofthepastorfuture,itonlyknowswhatitknowsthroughthecharacterswefollow,someofwhomareAmericansoldiers,someareinnocentIraqifamilies,othersareterrorists.Thismoviedoesawisethingbysimplyshowingthingsfromallpointsofview.Icantwaituntilitsreleasedbecauseitneedstobetalkedabout.Atthepremiereforthefilm,welearnthatmanyoftheactorsontheAmericanfrontareactuallysoldierswhofoughtinIraq.Theheadoftheplatoonisespeciallygood,andcouldgoonandhaveacareerasanactor.--------------------------------------------------30outof41peoplefoundthefollowingreviewuseful:Astorythatneededtobetold,13August20088/10Author:insomniafromAustraliaItsalmostimpossibletobetotallyobjectiveregardingasubjectaboutwhichoneistrulypassionate.ThewarinIraqisasubjectthatdividespeoplelikenootherinrecenttimes.Aswithanyconflict,thewarinIraqhasitssupportersanditsdetractors.Thereisnomiddleground.Therearenogreyareas:everythingisjustblackorwhite.Eitheryoubelieveitsajustifiablewar,oryoudont.ThisbringsmetoNickBroomfieldsnewfilm,quot;TheBattleForHadithaquot;.ThesubjectofthefilmiscontroversialasitdealswithanincidentinthecityofHaditha,allegedlyinvolvingtheUSMarines.Broomfieldusesactors,someofwhomareformerUSMarinesandIraqveterans,aswellasIraqirefugees,tofashionafilmthatsuccessfullystraddlesthegapbetweenaregulardocumentaryandastraightforwardfeaturefilm.Thefilmencompassesthreepointsofview:thoseoftheMarines,theinsurgents,andthefamilieswholivednearwheretheroadsidebombdetonated.ThisfilmisafictionalisedaccountofwhatactuallyhappenedatHaditha.Itshowsquitegraphically,thehorrorsofwarandwhattheAmericansaswellasinnocentIraqishavetogothroughalmostonadailybasis.Therearedeathsonbothsides,butitsIraqicivilianswhoarecaughtinthecrossfireandwhohavetobearthebruntofdealingwithmenwhohavebeenstretchedtobreakingpoint.ThefilminnowaycondonestheactionsofeithertheinsurgentsortheMarines.Itjustshowstheaudiencewhatmighthaveoccurredonthatfatefulday,anditsforthoseintheaudiencetomakeuptheirownmindsastowhowasintherightandwhowasinthewrong.Whenreadingsomeofthecommentspostedonthemessageboardforthisfilm,Ifinditsomewhatpuzzlingthatsomecontributorswritethatquot;BattleForHadithaquot;isanti-American.JustbecausetheUSMarinesareshowninalessthansympatheticlightinthisfilm,doesnotmeanthefilmisonthesideoftheinsurgents.Whatthefilmdoesdemonstrateishowquicklythingscangetoutofhand,inasituationsuchasthatinHaditha.Byallmeanscriticizeafilmonitsmerits,orlackofthem.Please,though,donotlabelthisfilmasun-Americanjustbecauseitdoesntfitablinkeredviewofthewaytheworldis.--------------------------------------------------26outof39peoplefoundthefollowingreviewuseful:betterthaniexpected,1April20088/10Author:SEVEREcriticfromBangladeshipersonallyneverheardofMr.Bloomfield,soihadnorealintentionofwatchingthisfilmtillisawitmentionedinthemessageboardsforotherfilms.thatsaid,imustsaythiswasthebestintherecentslewofIraqwarfilms(likeRedacted,HomeoftheBrave,etc.)ihalfexpectedittobelikeRedactedandwaspleasantlysurprisedtofinditmuchbetter.ithinkitreallybroughtoutthefactthattherearemultiplesidestoastory,anddidsowithouttoomuchbias.beingaMuslimmyselfimustadmitthatitseemedalittleinclinedtowardsIraqis,withMarinesportrayedasundisciplinedandemotionless(thoughoneoftheprotagonistsfeelsguiltandinrealitythisincidentcausedanuproar).therearenoA-listactors,whichinasense,actuallymadethemoviebetterbecauseyoualmostseetheactorsasthecharactersthemselves(especiallysincealotofthedialogisimprovised).ithinkitwaswellmade,andwellthoughtout.betterthanexpected.iwonderwhattheUSreactionwouldif/whenithasareleasethere?unlikeMooreswork(asstatedbyanotheruserhere)neitherpartyisshownascompletelyinnocentorcompletelyevil.imnotsureifthisisexactlyhowtheincidenttookplace,butifitis,thenthereiscertainlysomefoodforthoughtinthismovie.